When it comes to aircraft ownership, one of the most critical decisions pilots and investors face is whether to purchase an experimental aircraft or a certified aircraft. Each category has distinct advantages and drawbacks, making the choice highly dependent on the buyer’s priorities—whether that be cost, customization, maintenance, resale value, or long-term investment potential.
In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences between experimental and certified aircraft and examine which makes the better investment for different types of aviation enthusiasts and business-minded buyers.
Understanding the Differences: Certified vs. Experimental
Before diving into investment potential, it's essential to understand the regulatory and practical differences between these two categories.
Certified Aircraft
Certified aircraft are those that have been approved by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) through a rigorous certification process. These include aircraft from major manufacturers such as Cessna, Piper, Beechcraft, and Cirrus. Certified aircraft are subject to strict maintenance and operational regulations to ensure their reliability and safety.
Key Characteristics:
-
Must meet FAA airworthiness standards (Part 23 or Part 25 regulations)
-
Require certified replacement parts and repairs by FAA-licensed mechanics
-
Have higher operational reliability and insurance acceptability
-
Typically easier to finance due to proven safety records and established resale value
Experimental Aircraft
Experimental aircraft are typically homebuilt or kit-built aircraft that do not go through the FAA's standard certification process. These can range from innovative custom designs to aircraft built from kits provided by manufacturers like Van’s Aircraft, Lancair, or RANS.
Key Characteristics:
-
Built by individuals or experimental aircraft manufacturers
-
Less regulation on parts and maintenance, reducing costs
-
Greater room for performance customization (speed, avionics, aerodynamics)
-
May have restrictions on flight operations (e.g., cannot be used for commercial purposes)
-
Can require extensive owner involvement in maintenance and repairs
Investment Comparison: Which Offers Better Long-Term Value?
1. Initial Purchase Cost
-
Certified Aircraft: Generally more expensive upfront due to FAA certification requirements. A new Cessna 172 can cost between $400,000-$500,000, while used models still demand a premium due to their proven reliability.
-
Experimental Aircraft: Often significantly cheaper. A Van’s RV-10 kit, for example, costs around $75,000-$100,000 before assembly, while a completed, high-quality build can sell for $150,000-$250,000.
2. Maintenance and Operating Costs
-
Certified Aircraft: Require parts that are FAA-approved, which often leads to higher maintenance costs. Certified mechanics must perform inspections and repairs, adding to the expense.
-
Experimental Aircraft: Owners can often perform their own maintenance, and parts don’t need to be FAA-certified, resulting in much lower upkeep costs.
3. Insurance Costs
-
Certified Aircraft: Typically easier to insure because they have established safety records. Insurance companies provide more favorable rates due to predictable risk factors.
-
Experimental Aircraft: Higher insurance premiums due to unknown risks associated with builder quality and aircraft design. However, certain models (like the RV series) have established good safety records, leading to more competitive insurance rates.
4. Resale Value & Market Demand
-
Certified Aircraft: Hold their value well and often appreciate over time. The resale market is strong due to high demand for reliable, ready-to-fly aircraft.
-
Experimental Aircraft: Can be harder to resell, especially if built by an amateur with unknown workmanship quality. Buyers often scrutinize build logs and craftsmanship before purchasing.
5. Performance & Customization Potential
-
Certified Aircraft: Restricted to FAA-approved modifications. Less flexibility in upgrading avionics, engines, or performance enhancements.
-
Experimental Aircraft: Far more customization options. Owners can upgrade engines, install advanced avionics, and modify aerodynamics to optimize performance.
6. Operational Restrictions
-
Certified Aircraft: Allowed for a wide range of uses, including rental, flight training, and commercial operations.
-
Experimental Aircraft: Limited to personal and recreational use. Cannot be rented out or used for commercial flight training.
Which is the Better Investment?
Best for Long-Term Value & Resale Potential: Certified Aircraft
If you prioritize resale value, ease of insurance, and low-risk investment, a certified aircraft is the safer choice. It holds its value well and appeals to a broader market.
Best for Customization & Lower Operating Costs: Experimental Aircraft
If you want maximum customization, lower maintenance costs, and better performance at a lower price, experimental aircraft offer excellent value—but they require more owner involvement.
Final Takeaway
-
If you're looking for a safe investment with strong resale potential, certified aircraft are the way to go.
-
If you're a hands-on owner who values performance and affordability over resale value, experimental aircraft can be a rewarding and cost-effective choice.
Ultimately, the best investment depends on your aviation goals, budget, and willingness to take on maintenance responsibilities. Whichever route you choose, understanding these key differences will help you make a well-informed decision.